Trickle Down Collective Bargaining - Local Unions and the State CSEA Deal

September 9, 2011

The major concessions agreed to by CSEA in negotiations with New York State have been well publicized. The details of the 5-year deal include a wage freeze for the first three years, 2% increases in each of the last two years and immediate increases in employee contributions toward the cost of health insurance. The deal, which covers 66,000 State employees, will save New York $73 million in the first year alone. In turn, CSEA obtained a no-layoff pledge from Governor Cuomo for the first two years of the contract. Governor Cuomo had been threatening to layoff nearly 10,000 State employees if a contract could not be reached. Will other unions follow CSEA’s lead and accept this kind of deal?

Rick Karlin has an interesting article in the Albany Times-Union addressing this issue. According to the article, when asked about the odds of such a deal repeating itself at the local level, a CSEA spokesperson responded “If history is any precedent, zero.” But other reasonable unions may be getting the picture. The Syracuse Post-Standard reports that City of Syracuse firefighters ratified a two-year deal that includes two zero’s, along with increased contributions by the firefighters toward health insurance. In the most recent interest arbitration decision in New York, Oswego firefighters were awarded a 0% wage increase in the first year and 2% in the second year.

With a local, public sector workforce in New York that is five times the size of the State workforce, local union contracts that contain at least some of the State CSEA concessions will result in significant cost-savings for local governments. In light of the impending 2% property tax cap, this could be critically important to the fiscal health of local governments.

Overview